High-caliber artists make Bullseye the Staten Island Readers’ Choice for ‘Best Tattoo Parlor’ Modafferi’s 7-year-old business is a borough favorite, voted “Best Tattoo Parlor” by you in the Staten Island Readers’ Choice Awards. He says the reason why the shop won has a lot to do with the artists who work there. They’re professional artists, many with art degrees and previous careers as illustrators. Click to read more about the “Best Tattoo Shop”.